Parent information, milk, and teddy left for babysitter

How To Prepare For Your First Babysitter

(15 Essential Tips)

If you've been feeding and diapering your new baby for months, it's time for a break. But when you've never hired a babysitter before, it can certainly be an intimidating proposition.

Your mind probably fills with all of the things that could potentially go wrong if you leave your baby alone with a sitter. But with a little preparation, you can put the bulk of your worries to rest.

How do you prepare for your first babysitter? You'll need to mentally prepare yourself to leave your child alone with a sitter for the first time, as well as provide your babysitter with all the resources they'll need to succeed. You also want to plan in advance to make sure you have all the necessary supplies on hand.

In this article, you'll learn how to prepare your home, your child, and yourself for your first babysitter. Once you're set, you'll finally be ready to enjoy a dinner date or night out for the first time in months!

1. Ease Yourself Into It Gradually

The first time that you leave your child alone with a babysitter, you don't have to make it into a day-long ordeal. New parents always find the first time using a babysitter to be the hardest. So if you're nervous, make it fairly quick. Just go to a close restaurant around the corner and back home for your first baby-free date. Once you get used to the freedom and build up some trust with your sitter, you'll feel more confident going away longer amounts of time and further from home.

Understand that it's natural to have some initial apprehension about leaving your child alone for the first time with a stranger, or even a friend or family member. So if you need to take some baby steps to feel better about it, try to take things as gradually as you can.

How often should you hire a babysitter? Find out here - How Often Do You Use a Babysitter?

2. Don't Let Yourself Feel Guilty

If you're feeling any guilt about leaving your child at home with a babysitter, try your best to let go of it! Put things in perspective and remember that all parents will have someone else watch their children at some point. If not now, you definitely will need to learn to let go when it's time for daycare or preschool! So getting used to having a babysitter look after your child for a few hours is a great first step.

Know that you deserve some time away from your baby, and it doesn't make you a bad parent to want or need a break. Parenthood is very emotionally and physically draining. So give yourself permission to get a babysitter and get out of the house once and a while. Your baby will still be there when you get back!

3. Find A Babysitter You Can Trust

Before you can prepare for your first babysitter, first you have to find the right one! You'll want someone who has a personality that you feel like you get along with, and that you have a good gut feeling about.

There is normally an abundance of young girls (and some boys) looking for their first babysitting jobs in any given area. They might make fine babysitters once your child is a bit older. But if you have a newborn infant, it's better to find an older and more experienced babysitter for your first time.

Ideally, you'll want a sitter who is 16 or older. That way they're likely to be more mature and responsible than a babysitter who is only 12 or 13. They'll also likely have more direct experience with changing diapers and feeding babies.

To start your search for a babysitter, I recommend asking around to family and friends to see if they have any babysitters they've used in the past who they recommend.

If you're not sure where to get started, check our complete guide: The Best Ways to Hire a Babysitter.

Don't be afraid to interview several potential babysitters to make sure you find someone who's the perfect fit. You may even want to pick two or three favorites and have them complete a paid "working interview" where they watch the baby while you're still at home doing chores or other things in another room. That will give you a good idea of what kind of babysitter they actually are in action.

4. Work Out How Much You'll Pay

After you interview your babysitter, you should have an hourly rate in mind that you plan to pay them for their services. Present them with this information when you offer them the job, rather than keeping them wondering until you get home from the first time they babysit.

If you aren't sure how much to pay them, ask around to other parents you know to see what the going rate for a babysitter is in your area. It can vary a lot even city by city.

Most sitters prefer to be paid in cash. Be sure you stop by the bank or an ATM a couple days beforehand, to make sure you have some cash on hand to pay them with. Nowadays a lot of people pay for everything with their debit or credit card, so you might not automatically have cash that you carry around.

See our complete guide to babysitter pay for all the details that parents often ask about.

5. Make An Emergency Contact List

Your babysitter probably already knows the basics, like to call 911 (or your country’s emergency number) if a true emergency arises. But it's a good idea to make a complete emergency contact list just in case. You can include things like the number for poison control, as well as the numbers of some family, neighbors or friends they can reach for help if you're not available.

You should also include your cell phone number as well as the number for your spouse. Just make sure to discuss with your babysitter whether you want to receive a phone call for minor things like if your baby isn't eating or sleeping, or if you only want to be contacted in case of an emergency. It's good to give some examples of what sorts of things you do or don't consider to be an emergency.

6. Make A Schedule

Let your babysitter know what your typical timings are for sleep, feedings, and changes. Write them a list or schedule in advance so they can refer to it and make sure they're staying on track. That way they won't be feeling pressured or wondering if it's out of the ordinary for your baby to not be eating or sleeping at a given time.

Leave room in your schedule for your babysitter to make notes, check off tasks, or make any modifications they feel are necessary.

7. Leave Plenty of Milk or Formula

If you're pumping, you'll want to make sure there is lots of extra milk in the fridge to spare. For some babies, I swear they seem to work-up more of an appetite when their parents aren't around.

For moms who have been exclusively breastfeeding, don't make your babysitter the first one to find out if your baby will take a bottle or not. Practice bottle feeding at least a few weeks before you plan to use your babysitter to get your child used to it, so your babysitter is less likely to struggle.

If you're feeding formula, there's less planning required. But you should still make sure that you have plenty stocked up, as your sitter is unlikely to be able to go to the store if they run out.

8. Plan The Babysitter's Meals Out

If you plan on feeding your babysitter, you'll want to work out the details in advance. Usually, it's the norm if your sitter is working around dinner time to provide them with something to eat.

You might just tell them there are leftovers in the fridge or freezer, or stock your cupboard full of basic snacks. It can be something as simple as some granola bars or bags of popcorn. If you're really nice, you might offer to order a pizza or some other kind of takeout for them!

Let your babysitter know what they are allowed to eat. And equally importantly, let them know what they can't eat. If they don't have permission to go into the fridge, make sure to let them know that. Especially if there's something really tasty in there you're hoping to eat the next day, because it would be a shame if it wasn't there when you got home!

Are you supposed to provide dinner for your babysitter? Find out what's the norm in this article - Do You Provide Dinner for Your Babysitter? and see our recommended food ideas that are easy to prepare.

9. Write An Information List

Your information list should include most of the information your babysitter might want or need to know. Depending on how much information you want to share, it may be several pages long.

Some basic things you definitely want to include are:

  • Your full address
  • Information on where you are going to be while you're out
  • Contact information for your child's doctor
  • Any known allergies your child has, or special health instructions

You might also want to share some more optional stuff such as your WiFi and Netflix password, how to use the stove or washing machine, and where to find extra diapers, blankets, or other supplies.

For a full list of information to provide your babysitter with, check out this article - What Information Do You Leave for a Babysitter? and download our handy checklist.

10. Give Your Babysitter A House Tour

The first time you have a new babysitter come to your house, it's good for them to show up 10 minutes early so that you can give them a tour and show them around your home.

This will show them where all the important things like your first-aid kit, circuit breaker, washing machines, home alarm, and other items are located which a babysitter might need to use at some point. As well as a basic layout of your house and where the washroom and other rooms are located.

A tour is great because it might also prompt you to think of things you hadn't written down on your information list, and it also gives your babysitter a chance to ask any questions of their own that they may have.

11. Set Your House Rules

There are certain things you may want your babysitter to do or not do. And although some of them might seem obvious to you, they aren't necessarily so obvious to everyone else!

Some rules you may include are:

  • Not leaving the house with your child
  • Never leaving your child alone
  • Not giving your child any medicine
  • Don't give your child any raw carrots, nuts, or any other smooth hard foods they might choke on.
  • No sleeping on the job (you'd be surprised!)
  • Any places either the babysitter or your child isn't allowed to be, or things they're not allowed to do. (Like going in your bedroom, or using the family computer)
  • Whether or not your pets are allowed on the furniture

12. Set One Place To Keep All Your Paperwork

You should decide on one central place that you plan to keep all of your paperwork related to the babysitter. Usually, the kitchen makes the most sense. You can either leave things on the counter or put some of it on the fridge with a magnet.

That way your babysitter knows where to go if there is any information they need answers to. All of your emergency contacts, information lists, calendars, house rules, and worksheets can be kept together. It also makes sense to leave a pen and pad of paper in case your babysitter needs to take any phone messages, or she just wants to write some notes during the course of their babysitting.

13. Make Some Extra Sets of Keys

Even though it's pretty unlikely that your new babysitter will be leaving the home with your newborn, it doesn't hurt to have a spare set of keys to leave with them. If nothing else, they might need to lock up in case of an emergency, like if they need to take your child to the hospital.

If there are any rooms, drawers, or other things in your home that lock which the babysitter might need to open, be sure to leave an extra key for those as well.

Not feeling comfortable leaving a set of keys for your babysitter? You can leave them with a neighbor you trust or a relative who lives closeby instead if you prefer.

14. Hide Any Personal Items In Advance

Your babysitter will have full access to your house, and will probably need to access most of the rooms over the course of their time there.

Take a walk around your home for any personal items that are just laying out that you might not want the babysitter to see. This can include stuff like open mail and bills, medication, or anything else in your home that you aren't comfortable with a stranger seeing.

It's unlikely that a babysitter will go snooping through your things anyway, but it's always good to just remove the temptation entirely.

15. Have Questions To Ask When You Get Home

After you get home, you'll want an update from the babysitter about how the night went.

You can ask them questions like how your child behaved, if there were any problems, or whether any questions came up that they want the answer to for next time.

Following up with your babysitter will also potentially point out any shortcomings, things you forgot about or overlooked, or general ways to make a better experience for both of you next time.

Remember That You're In Control

It sure might not always feel like it, but you're the responsible, mature adult in this situation. Your babysitter is likely a teenager with limited experience who will look to you for instruction and guidance on how to do their job.

Your babysitter is essentially almost your employee, so the more details and structure you can give them, the easier and more clear it will be for them in terms of how to perform their job duties and understand what you expect of them.

Conclusion

As a new parent, you're probably pretty torn between feeling exhausted and needing a break, but not feeling like you can trust anyone else with your baby. But using a babysitter is nothing to be afraid of. Especially if you've done your due diligence to properly interview them and complete a background check, and you feel like you've found someone that's a good fit.

Eventually, you will have done everything you can to prepare. So don't overthink it. If you've done everything discussed in this article, you're probably in a really great position to leave your baby with a babysitter for the first time. Now it's just time to take that first step out the door, and back to having a free evening every once and a while to get out of the house.

Next:

Written and Illustrated by:

Matthew Taylor

Matthew Taylor

Kidsit Founder, Editor, Illustrator, Web Developer, and father of three beautiful kids in Sydney, Australia.

Published: 8 September 2019

More Babysitting Tips

Babysitter and child with separation anxiety

How To Prepare Your Child For A Babysitter (9 Separation Anxiety Tips)

Solve separation anxiety issues by trying our 9 handy tips and you can be leaving your child with a babysitter sooner than you think!

Do Babysitters Wash Dishes & Do Other Chores? (What to Expect)

Learn whether a babysitter should do any cleaning as well as what types of cleaning you should and shouldn't expect them to do.

What Information Do You Leave for a Babysitter? (Bonus Checklist Below)

Give your babysitter all the information they need by printing out our handy parent details form. Never forget important instructions.

Family going on vacation

Vacation Babysitters (12 Solutions For Relaxing Family Holidays)

We cover the best childcare options that are available to families while on vacation that both kids and parents will love.

NYE babysitter with baby

How To Hire A Babysitter For New Year's Eve (Cost & Requirements)

Learn how to hire a babysitter for New Year's Eve, what the requirements are, whether you need a backup sitter, and how much it will cost you!

The Best Ways to Hire a Babysitter (The Complete Guide)

Follow our step by step guide to hiring a babysitter from start to finish including screening, interviewing, performing background checks, and making an offer.

Babysitter background check

How to Run a Background Check on a Babysitter (The Complete Guide)

Learn the types of babysitter background checks that are available for safety and peace of mind and which ones are right for you.

Babysitter search

What to Look For in a Babysitter (12 Essential Qualities)

Learn which qualities and characteristics a babysitter should have that make them a great caregiver your whole family will love.

Bad babysitter

Warning Signs of a Bad Babysitter (18 Red Flags to Watch Out For!)

Learn the warning signs of a bad babysitter so you can take action as soon as possible and keep your family safe.

Benefits Of Hiring A Babysitter (42 Unexpected Advantages)

Learn some non-obvious benefits when it comes to hiring a babysitter for your child or children. We'll also touch on a few of the disadvantages to consider.

What Age Do You Stop Needing A Babysitter? (Age & Maturity Guide)

Learn how old, mature and capable your kids need to be before you can be comfortable leaving them home without a babysitter.

Autistic child with babysitter and parent

How to Find a Babysitter for an Autistic Child (The Complete Guide)

This guide will answer all of your questions about finding, vetting, teaching, and working with the right babysitter for your autistic child.

Babysitter pay

Babysitter Pay (The Complete Guide for Parents)

Learn how much babysitters get paid in various countries and cities, and how to price a babysitter for your specific situation.

Nanny cam

Is It Legal to Record a Babysitter? (What the Law Says)

Learn the basic laws that various countries have about recording people with or without their consent, and see the pros and cons of using a nanny cam.

43 Babysitter Interview Questions (And What Responses to Look For)

Make sure your babysitter is capable, experienced, is a great fit for your family, and has a great personality too by asking the right questions.

How Often Do You Use a Babysitter? (Learn What's Right For You)

The majority of families will need to hire a babysitter between once per week and 1-2 times per month but it depends on your family's individual needs.

Is it Safe to Hire a Male Babysitter? (Facts and Stats You Should Know)

A male babysitter can be just as safe, caring, and responsible as a female one. Compare their qualifications and recommendations just like other candidates.

Doctor examining a child

Can a Babysitter Take a Child to the Doctor? (How to Grant Permission)

Learn what paperwork is required to allow your babysitter to take your child to the doctor if you’re unavailable to do so.

Babysitter eating a sandwich and an apple

Do You Provide Dinner for Your Babysitter? (Try These 8 Easy Food Ideas)

Learn what babysitters expect from parents when it comes to food. If you decide to provide dinner, try our 8 easy food ideas that are perfect for babysitters on the job.